Momentous Collagen vs Vital Proteins: An Honest Comparison
|
Learn how two popular collagen supplements—Momentous Collagen and Vital Proteins—stack up in this head-to-head comparison.
Momentous and Vital Proteins are two brands that offer premium collagen supplements.
Both brands have garnered attention for their high-quality ingredients, rigorous standards, and expansive range of products. However, consumers often need help determining which brand better suits their health and performance needs in terms of the supplements offered, their quality, and sourcing practices.
At Momentous, we understand the importance of making informed decisions about your health. While we could easily focus only on our products' strengths, an honest comparison will serve you better.
This article aims to provide a transparent overview of how Momentous collagen products stack up against products offered by Vital Proteins. Our goal is to empower you to choose the brand and specific supplements that align best with your health and performance priorities.
Before we get into a detailed comparison of Momentous and Vital Proteins, here’s a quick summary below of what we’ve covered in this article:
| Aspect | Momentous | Vital Proteins |
|---|---|---|
| Collagen Product Overview | Collagen Peptides and Collagen Travel Packs | 15+ collagen products |
| Third-Party Certifications | NSF Certified, Informed Sport Certified | NSF Certified |
| Free Shipping | Free shipping on orders over $75 | Free shipping on orders over $50 |
| Unique Advantages | Combines bovine collagen, vitamin C, and FORTIGEL®, Collaborates with top experts, NSF and Informed Sport certified, Transparent manufacturing process, 30-day satisfaction guarantee | High-quality, purpose-driven ingredients, Facility is cGMP certified, 30-day return policy, B Corp Certified |
| Final Takeaway | Focus on no fillers/additives, collaboration with scientists and experts, rigorous testing and certification. | Focus on premium collagen products, sustainability, acquired by Nestlé but operates independently. |
An Overview of Momentous Collagen
Momentous Collagen delivers 15 grams of collagen in two forms, 10 grams of grass-fed bovine collagen peptides plus 5g of FORTIGEL®, a patented, clinically researched collagen peptide source designed to promote collagen synthesis in tendons and ligaments.
The Momentous Collagen formula also includes vitamin C and provides essential amino acids that support the synthesis of new collagen fibers, improving tissue health and function. It is free from fat, sugar, cholesterol, purines, and additives for a clean nutritional profile.
Momentous Collagen can help improve joint health and mobility, support soft tissue development, aid in muscle recovery, and help promote healthy hair, skin, and nails. For optimal results, Momentous advises consuming its collagen 45-60 minutes before training or, if using for health and wellbeing benefits, use daily as desired.
Collagen is the most abundant protein in our body and plays a vital role in maintaining the structural integrity of our skin, bones, muscles, tendons, and ligaments. It is produced naturally in our bodies, but its production decreases as we age. That’s why collagen supplementation can be helpful to improve collagen production and synthesis in our bodies, build resilience against injury, as well as aid in recovery from tendon and/or ligament injuries.
Collagen Products Offered
Momentous offers the following collagen products:
Collagen Peptides: 30 servings per 1.12lb container, 15g of collagen per serving
Collagen Travel Packs: 10 single-serve packets, 15g of collagen per serving
Certifications
Momentous prides itself on sourcing high-quality ingredients in its products and gaining independent third-party certifications from leading testing organizations such as the NSF and Informed Sport . Both of its collagen products are certified by Informed Sport and NSF Certified for Sport, the NSF’s highest certification.
Highlights
Momentous Collagen is a unique formula that combines 11.6 grams of grass-fed bovine collagen with 5.2 grams of FORTIGEL ® plus 50mg of vitamin C and 15g of protein. FORTIGEL contains a hydrolyzed form of collagen broken down into smaller peptides, which helps increase absorption by the body and maximizes stimulation of the human cell types involved in biosynthesis. Vitamin C is included in the formula to help increase collagen formation and aid in the development of stronger collagen.
Its travel packs make it easy and hassle-free to take collagen with you when you’re on the go, be it post-gym workout or while on vacation.
Expert Partners
Momentous works with the greatest minds in science, psychology, and human performance who together have decades of academic and in-the-field experience in health, wellbeing, fitness, and performance.
Among these experts are:
Dr. Kelly Starrett (physical therapist and three-time New York Times bestselling author)
Dr. Stacy Sims (author and expert on female physiology and nutrition)
Dr. Andy Galpin (PhD in human bioenergetics and coach to elite athletes)
Jordan Mazur (Director of Nutrition for an NFL team)
Brandon McDaniel (VP of Player Performance for an MLB team)
An Overview of Vital Proteins
Vital Proteins is a wellness brand that offers a wide range of premium collagen-based products that includes powders, capsules, and gummies. The company’s mission is to help people feel, look, and move at their best.
Collagen Products Offered
Vital Proteins offers a comprehensive range of collagen products that includes more than 15 different powders. Best sellers include Collagen Peptides Advanced, Chocolate Collagen Peptides, and Vital Performance Protein Powder.
Popular options among its capsule products include Cartilage Collagen and Mind+Memory Boost. It offers four different gummy products, including Collagen Gummies and Apple Cider Vinegar Gummies.
Certifications
Vital Proteins has a sports nutrition product line, Vital Performance. All products in this range are NSF Certified for Sport.
Many of its products are non-GMO tested and certified while others are Whole30 approved.
Highlights
One of the clear highlights of the Vital Proteins product portfolio is its sheer breadth with products spanning more than 10 categories, including Wellness, Energy, Sleep, Bones & Joints, Hair, Skin, and Nails. It also offers a number of flavors, such as Matcha and Lemon, as well as Marine Collagen (made from the scales of fresh, non-GMO Certified, wild-caught cod) and Collagen Creamer.
It is a B Corp Certified business, meaning it meets high standards of transparency and accountability to its employees, customers and society at large across environmental, customer service, workforce, governance, and community issues.
Expert Partners
Jennifer Aniston was such a fan of Vital Proteins products that she became its Chief Creative Officer in 2020 (after reportedly using the products since 2016). She is reported to love Vital Proteins’ skincare benefits.
Other brand ambassadors include American middle distance runner Colleen Quigley; Silvy Arujo, a Columbian health and fitness YouTube star; and Chase Tucker, a health coach, personal trainer, and former Peloton instructor.
A Side-by-Side Comparison of Momentous and Vital Proteins
INGREDIENTS AND FORMULATIONS
Momentous
No fillers or additives are used.
Momentous works with some of the world's leading scientists who use the latest research to help develop best-in-class products, often using patented ingredients and direct clinical proof.
Momentous also works with performance experts from the NFL to the NCAA who share their knowledge from elite sports to help bring truly innovative products to market.
Vital Proteins
Vital Proteins prioritizes sourcing high-quality, purpose-driven ingredients.
Find out more about 20+ ingredients used in their products here.
Some products hold third-party certifications from reputable organizations, like NSF, Rainforest Alliance, and Whole30.
PRODUCT PURITY AND QUALITY
Momentous
All products are manufactured in a facility that is certified and audited by the NSF, the world’s foremost product testing organization.
The NSF inspects our facilities and audits our entire production process annually.
It also conducts additional unannounced inspections: NSF inspectors test raw materials, observe batch control processes and internal lab capabilities, check for cross-contamination mitigation, machine cleaning protocols, and much more.
Some products are also Informed Sport-certified.
Vital Proteins
Products in the Vital Performance product line are NSF Certified for Sport.
The Vital Proteins manufacturing facility is an NSF certified cGMP (current Good Manufacturing Practices) facility.
Some products are Kosher-certified, non-GMO tested, certified, or Whole 30-approved.
MANUFACTURING STANDARDS
Momentous
Momentous takes a rigorous approach to manufacturing supplements, setting themselves apart in an industry often criticized for lax regulations. They are committed to transparency and quality, manufacturing every product in NSF-certified facilities which undergo regular and surprise inspections to ensure purity and compliance.
Momentous extends its commitment to safety by participating in NSF Sport and Informed Sport testing, ensuring each product batch is free of banned substances and contaminants before reaching the market. This meticulous process, though costly and time-consuming, underscores the dedication to delivering trustworthy, high-performance supplements to customers.
Vital Proteins
The Vital Proteins manufacturing facility is both NSF and SQF Certified ensuring it meets Global Food Safety Initiative (GFSI) standards. All canisters, capsules bottles, and stick pack film are BPA/BPS free.
Vital Proteins’ website states that each of its formulations is consciously developed to be efficacious, easy to use, and enjoyable to consume: “We a) prioritize sourcing high-quality, purpose-driven ingredients, b) pursue social, environmental and dietary certifications and c) maintain extensive quality processes and procedures at our manufacturing facilities.”
CUSTOMER SERVICE AND SATISFACTION
Momentous
Due to the consumable nature of our products and stringent quality standards, Momentous does not accept returns once products have been delivered. This ensures that the supplements maintain our high standard from production to consumption.
However, customers do have a 60-minute window post-purchase to make any changes to their order, including cancellations.
For any issues that arise post-delivery, Momentous encourages customers to contact their customer service team, who are ready and eager to assist, ensuring customer satisfaction through proactive support. Momentous stands by all of its products with a 30-day satisfaction guarantee. If for any reason you are not satisfied with your product(s) within 30 days of delivery, you can contact the help center.
Vital Proteins
Vital Proteins accepts returns within 30 days of receipt.
Orders are usually processed and shipped within one business day.
A comprehensive FAQ page with common customer service questions is available here.
SUSTAINABILITY AND ETHICAL PRACTICES
Momentous
Momentous has recently introduced BPA-free, recyclable (HDPE 2) plastic containers. The material used to produce our new containers—the same material used in milk cartons—is believed to be one of the most frequently recycled materials.
Vital Proteins
Vital Proteins is B Corp Certified and prioritizes social and environmental responsibility.
Its website states that it is “committed to doing business in a way that respects people and the planet.”
It aims for all of its products to be scoopless by the end of 2024, stating: “This small action will remove more than 25 million plastic scoops out of circulation this year alone amounting to 250K+ pounds annually.”
PRICING
This table shows a price comparison for the two most comparable products offered by Momentous and Vital Proteins:
| Momentous | Vital Proteins | |
|---|---|---|
| Collagen Peptides (Price Per Serving) | $1.73 | $1.68 (when purchasing the 20oz Collagen Peptides) |
| Collagen Travel Packs | $3.79 | Currently unavailable on Vital Proteins’ website |
| Subscribe & Save Plans | 25% off first subscription order of any size, 10% off thereafter | 15% off any subscription |
SHIPPING
Momentous
Free shipping on all orders $75+
International shipping (customers in 200+ countries)
Vital Proteins
Free shipping on all orders $50+
No international shipping, but there are international distributors in 30+ countries worldwide. Full list available here.
OVERALL
Momentous
Momentous is dedicated to crafting supplements with no fillers or additives, collaborating with leading scientists and performance experts to produce innovative, high-quality products. All Momentous supplements are rigorously tested and certified by NSF and Informed Sport, ensuring they meet strict standards for purity and effectiveness.
Our manufacturing process is transparent, focusing on delivering products that athletes and active people can trust. While Momentous maintains a strict no-return policy on delivered products, they emphasize customer service and satisfaction, offering support and modifications within a short window after purchase.
Vital Proteins
Vital Proteins is a health and wellness brand dedicated to helping people look, feel, and move at their best. It offers premium collagen-based products designed to help improve hair, skin, nails, bones and joints, sleep, energy, and energy.
It is a Certified B Corp and fosters growth in its business and employees. It offers returns with 30 days of receipt and free shipping on all orders over $50. Nestlé Health Science, a subsidiary of the Swiss food giant Nestlé, acquired a majority stake in Vital Proteins in 2020. It continues to operate as a standalone business.
Ready to try one of the highest-quality collagen supplements designed for everyday performance?
Emma-Kate Lidbury
Emma-Kate Lidbury is a freelance writer and editor with 20 years of experience working in the health and fitness world.
